How to Overcome Common Challenges in Breaststroke

Breaststroke has a strange reputation among the four competitive strokes. It's the one most beginner swimmers pick up first, sometimes informally, without ever being properly taught — and yet it's also widely considered the most technically demanding stroke to actually swim well, even among advanced and competitive swimmers. Unlike freestyle or backstroke, which rely on alternating, continuous limb movement, breaststroke is built entirely around simultaneous, symmetrical movements that create distinct, separate phases of power and glide. That structure is precisely what makes the stroke so unforgiving of small timing errors: a timing mistake that might cost a freestyler a tenth of a second can cost a breaststroker several tenths, because it collapses the glide phase entirely and turns what should be an efficient, flowing stroke into a swimmer fighting the water rather than riding through it.
This article works through the most common challenges swimmers of every level face in breaststroke — timing and sequencing, the kick, the pull, breathing coordination, body position and undulation, the underwater pullout, and the persistent misconception that faster stroke rate means faster swimming — along with the specific drills and cues used to correct each one.
1. Understanding Why Timing Is the Root of Almost Everything
Before addressing individual challenges, it's worth understanding the underlying principle that explains most of them: breaststroke's power comes from sequential timing, not simultaneous motion. The basic cycle should follow a clear order — pull, breathe, kick, glide — with each phase completing before the next fully begins, rather than the arms and legs working at the same time. When pull, breath, kick, and glide blur together into one blended motion, drag spikes dramatically and momentum dies almost immediately, since the propulsive force generated by one limb pair gets partially cancelled out by the drag created by the other limb pair moving through the water at the same moment.
This is not a minor technical nuance — it's the central organizing principle of the entire stroke. Elite breaststrokers are frequently cited as generating the overwhelming majority of their total propulsion from the kick alone, but only when that kick is executed with genuinely precise timing relative to the rest of the stroke cycle. A recurring line among coaches working on this exact problem is that breaststroke isn't broken by big, obvious mistakes — it's broken by tiny timing errors that compound with every single stroke cycle, each one bleeding away a small amount of momentum that adds up considerably over a full length or race.
There's also a subtler timing detail that surprises many self-taught swimmers: the kick doesn't wait until the pull is completely finished before beginning. Around halfway to two-thirds of the way through the pull, the kick actually begins to load and prepare, creating a slight, deliberate overlap that keeps momentum continuous rather than allowing a dead gap between the two phases — without ever letting the arms and legs generate drag against each other by moving forcefully at the exact same instant. This overlap is a genuinely advanced detail, but understanding that "sequential" doesn't mean "with long empty pauses between phases" helps avoid overcorrecting into an overly robotic, disconnected stroke.
2. Challenge: Pulling and Kicking at the Same Time
The problem. By far the most commonly cited breaststroke error is performing the arm pull and leg kick simultaneously, or spacing them too far apart, rather than in the correct overlapping sequence. When these two movements don't complement each other's timing, a swimmer loses momentum specifically during what should be the glide phase — the part of the stroke that's meant to be the most efficient, drag-free portion of the entire cycle.
Why it happens and what it feels like. Swimmers experiencing this issue often describe their stroke as feeling choppy or erratic rather than smooth, notice they're fatiguing faster than the effort should justify, and feel like they're fighting or pushing through the water rather than gliding across it. A useful self-diagnostic is simply paying attention to where a stroke "feels stuck" — bobbing up and down rather than moving forward, or legs working hard but barely generating forward movement, are both classic signs that pull-kick timing has broken down.
The fix. The correct sequence is pull, breathe, kick, glide — arms complete their pulling motion (with the breath integrated into that same phase, discussed further below), the legs then execute the kick, and the body finishes each cycle in a brief, deliberate glide in full streamline before the next pull begins.
Drills to fix it. Breaking the stroke down into deliberately separated component parts, with intentional pauses inserted between each phase, is a widely recommended way to internalize correct sequencing before trying to blend the phases into a smoother, continuous stroke — essentially over-exaggerating the separation temporarily so the body learns the correct order, then gradually tightening the phases together once the sequence itself feels automatic. A pull buoy held between the thighs, used to practice the arm pull in complete isolation from any kick, followed by separate isolated kick drills, is another effective way to separate the two movements before recombining them. Vertical breaststroke — treading water in deep water using only the breaststroke arm and leg movements for sustained intervals of around 30 seconds — is a particularly powerful diagnostic and training tool here, because there's no forward motion to mask a timing error: if the arms and legs are moving simultaneously rather than sequentially, the swimmer will simply sink, providing immediate, unambiguous feedback that no amount of horizontal swimming would give as clearly.
3. Challenge: Pausing in the Wrong Place
The problem. Even swimmers who understand the correct pull-breathe-kick-glide order often make a specific, subtle version of the timing mistake: they pause during the breath, rather than during the glide.
Why it matters. This is a genuinely important distinction, and one that coaches consistently flag as one of the mistakes they see most often. The moment a swimmer is taking a breath is also the moment their body is in its least streamlined, highest-drag position of the entire stroke cycle — head and shoulders lifted, hips typically dropping slightly as a result. Pausing specifically at this point means holding the body in its worst possible position for drag, precisely when a pause should least be happening. The pull and breath should instead function as one quick, continuous motion, with the genuine pause — the deliberate rest point of the stroke — occurring only once the body has returned to a full, streamlined glide position.
The fix. Think of the pull and breath as a single fast, connected action, immediately followed by the kick, and only then followed by a short, purposeful glide of roughly one to two seconds in full streamline before beginning the next cycle.
Drills to fix it. A glide-count drill — silently counting a fixed count (something like "one, two") during every glide phase before initiating the next pull — gives a swimmer a simple, self-administered check on timing: if the count can't be held without speed collapsing to a complete stop, the glide itself may be running too long, but if a swimmer never manages to reach the count at all, they're rushing straight from the kick into the next pull without any real glide at all. Practicing the stroke for short distances without breathing at all is another useful correction, since removing the breath temporarily eliminates the specific point in the cycle where this mistake tends to occur, making the underlying pull-kick-glide timing considerably easier to feel and internalize in isolation.
4. Challenge: Rushing the Stroke Rate Instead of Maximizing Distance Per Stroke
The problem. A specific and somewhat counterintuitive mistake, particularly common among competitive swimmers, is confusing a faster stroke rate with faster overall swimming. Some swimmers, especially when trying to increase speed or when anxious about losing momentum, go straight from the kick into the next pull with essentially zero pause — producing a high stroke rate, a lot of visible splashing, and surprisingly little actual forward movement.
Why it matters. In breaststroke specifically, distance covered per stroke generally matters more than sheer stroke turnover for the vast majority of swimmers and events. Eliminating the glide entirely in pursuit of a higher stroke rate sacrifices exactly the phase of the stroke that generates the most efficient, drag-free distance, trading a small amount of raw turnover speed for a much larger loss in the actual distance each stroke cycle produces.
The fix. Deliberately glide for a full one to two seconds after each kick, resisting the instinct to rush immediately into the next pull, and trust that the resulting stroke — slower in raw cycle count but covering considerably more distance per cycle — will typically be faster overall than a rushed, glide-free version of the same stroke.
Drills to fix it. A stroke-count challenge — swimming a fixed distance like 25 metres, counting the total number of strokes taken, and then repeating the same distance while deliberately trying to reduce that count — directly targets this issue by rewarding a swimmer for covering more ground per stroke cycle rather than simply moving the arms and legs more often.
5. Challenge: Kicking Too Wide
The problem. Many swimmers, under the belief that a wider kick generates more propulsive power, let their knees travel out beyond shoulder width during the leg recovery and kick.
Why it matters. While a wider kick can genuinely pull more water in a given instant, it also significantly increases resistance and reduces overall kicking power once the legs move past roughly shoulder width, since the legs are now displacing considerably more water — and creating considerably more drag — than a more compact kick would. The net effect tends to be a net loss rather than a net gain: more effort and more resistance, without a proportional increase in useful forward propulsion.
The fix. Ideally, the knees should stay within roughly the body's own width — not flaring out noticeably beyond the shoulders — keeping the kick more compact and reducing the amount of water displaced sideways rather than propulsively backward.
Drills to fix it. The SLOB drill (streamline on back) — lying in a streamlined position on the back and performing the breaststroke kick while specifically keeping the knees under the surface of the water throughout — is a widely used correction for this exact issue, since it makes any excessive knee width immediately visible and easy to self-correct, without the added complexity of also managing the arm pull and breathing at the same time.
6. Challenge: Illegal or Asymmetrical Kicks (the Scissors Kick)
The problem. A specific and genuinely serious technical fault, particularly relevant for competitive swimmers, is failing to turn both feet outward symmetrically during the kick — one foot rotates outward while the other stays turned inward, producing what's known as a scissors kick.
Why it matters. Beyond simply being technically inefficient, an asymmetrical scissors kick is one of the specific kick faults that can result in disqualification under competitive breaststroke rules, since the stroke's rules require simultaneous, symmetrical movement of the legs throughout the kick.
The fix. Both feet need to rotate outward together and symmetrically during the kick's outward and whip phases, rather than one foot doing the work while the other stays in a more neutral or inward position.
Drills to fix it. Filming the kick from underwater, or from directly behind while a swimmer kicks with a kickboard, makes an asymmetrical scissors pattern considerably easier to spot than it typically feels from the swimmer's own internal perspective, since this kind of left-right imbalance often isn't something a swimmer can reliably feel without external visual feedback.
7. Challenge: Pulling Too Wide
The problem. Mirroring the wide-kick mistake described above, some swimmers pull their arms too far outward during the catch and outsweep in an attempt to generate more power, sweeping well beyond shoulder width before beginning the inward pulling motion.
Why it matters. As with an overly wide kick, an overly wide pull creates unnecessary drag and wastes energy without proportionally increasing propulsion, since the strongest, most effective part of the breaststroke pull comes from the forearms pressing directly backward during the catch, not from how far outward the arms initially sweep.
The fix. A more compact pull — keeping the elbows high and sweeping the arms outward only to roughly shoulder width before sweeping them back inward — generates a stronger, more efficient catch than an exaggerated wide sweep, while also reducing unnecessary drag.
Drills to fix it. Sculling drills, performed at the front of the stroke, help build a genuine physical feel for the water during the catch phase specifically, reinforcing correct, compact arm movement and a strong forward press rather than relying on width to generate power.
8. Challenge: Breathing at the Wrong Point in the Cycle
The problem. Related to but distinct from the general timing issues discussed earlier, breathing specifically at the wrong moment in the stroke cycle — too late, too abruptly, or disconnected from the natural rise of the shoulders during the pull — causes unnecessary head movement, which in turn increases drag and disrupts the streamlined body position the rest of the stroke is working to maintain.
Why it matters. Because the breath naturally coincides with the highest-drag portion of the stroke cycle, getting its timing wrong doesn't just cost a swimmer air-management efficiency — it actively compounds the drag problem at exactly the point in the cycle where the body is already least streamlined.
The fix. The inhale should begin as soon as the outward sweep of the arms starts and the shoulders naturally begin to rise out of the water — not after the pull is already underway or nearly finished. By the time the hands sweep back inward toward the chest, the breath itself should already be essentially complete, so that the head can return to a neutral, forward-looking position in time for the kick and glide phases without any additional delay.
Drills to fix it. For beginners specifically, practicing the arm motion and breath timing while standing in shallow water — without the added complexity and pressure of full-stroke swimming — allows the correct rhythm to be learned and internalized before combining it with the kick and glide. A simple, repeatable cue like "breathe with the pull, not after the pull" gives swimmers something concrete to focus on mid-swim, rather than needing to consciously track every individual phase of the cycle at once.
9. Challenge: Excessive Bobbing and Poor Body Position
The problem. Some swimmers bob dramatically up and down with each stroke cycle rather than maintaining a relatively level, controlled trajectory, or introduce excessive undulation — a pronounced up-and-down wave motion through the body — well beyond what the stroke actually calls for.
Why it matters. While breaststroke does involve a degree of natural undulation, unlike the flatter body position used in freestyle or backstroke, excessive vertical movement wastes energy on motion that doesn't contribute to forward progress and typically signals an underlying timing problem — often the same simultaneous-arm-and-leg-movement issue discussed earlier — rather than being an intentional stylistic choice.
The fix. The goal is a controlled, moderate rise and fall through the stroke cycle — the shoulders and head naturally lift somewhat during the pull and breath, and the body naturally extends into a flatter position during the glide — without the exaggerated, energy-wasting bobbing that comes from poor timing or an overly dramatic undulating motion through the hips and torso.
Drills to fix it. The SLOB drill mentioned earlier, alongside its front-facing counterpart, often called SLOF (streamline on front) — holding a streamlined position on the front, performing the breaststroke kick, and timing a breathing lift without actually performing a pull — helps isolate and correct body position issues independent of the arm stroke, letting a swimmer feel what a controlled, appropriately moderate body position should actually feel like. A pool noodle tucked under the hips is sometimes used as a temporary support for beginners specifically struggling to feel the correct position, giving some physical, tactile feedback about where the hips should sit in the water.
10. Challenge: The Underwater Pullout
The problem. Immediately following a start or a turn, breaststroke swimmers are permitted a single underwater pullout — one long, powerful arm pull combined with a single breaststroke kick and, depending on personal preference and rules, an optional dolphin kick — before surfacing into full-stroke swimming. Many swimmers, particularly those newer to competitive breaststroke, execute this phase poorly: rushing it, mistiming the dolphin kick relative to the pull, or surfacing too early or too late relative to where their actual speed advantage from the pullout has faded.
Why it matters. The biggest genuine challenge with the pullout is that it demands real patience precisely at the moment a swimmer is most impatient to breathe and begin normal stroke rhythm, having just completed a start or turn without having taken a breath in some time. Rushing the pullout to get to a breath sooner sacrifices what is otherwise one of the fastest phases of any breaststroke length, since a well-executed underwater pullout, like the underwater phases of other strokes, generates more speed than the swimmer can typically sustain once they surface into normal stroke cycling.
The fix. There isn't a single universally agreed-upon "correct" placement for the optional dolphin kick within the pullout — some swimmers perform it before the main pull begins, others incorporate it near the end of the pulling motion — and swimmers are generally encouraged to experiment and settle on whichever timing feels most natural and effective for their own body and stroke rhythm, rather than assuming there's one definitively superior technique that applies to everyone.
Drills to fix it. Practicing underwater pullouts specifically and repeatedly off the wall, separate from full lengths of swimming, is an effective way to isolate and refine this phase, since — much like the sequential pull-kick-glide pattern of the full stroke — the pullout is essentially a miniature version of breaststroke's core timing principle, with the specific added advantage of having no breathing variable to manage or disrupt the sequence.
11. Diagnosing Your Own Specific Challenge Before Fixing It
Given how many distinct challenges breaststroke can present, a sensible starting point before attempting any specific correction is a short, honest self-diagnostic swim: covering a modest distance — say, four repeats of 25 metres — at a moderate, comfortable pace, and paying close attention to exactly where the stroke feels stuck, inefficient, or effortful rather than smooth. Specific sensations tend to map fairly reliably back to specific underlying issues: a feeling of bobbing up and down rather than moving cleanly forward typically points toward a timing problem, a body position problem, or both; legs working hard while barely producing forward movement often points toward a wide or mistimed kick; and a generally choppy, disconnected feeling throughout the stroke usually traces back to the fundamental pull-breathe-kick-glide sequencing discussed at the start of this article.
Filming your own stroke — ideally from underwater or from the side, since these angles reveal timing and body position issues far more clearly than a swimmer's own internal sense of the stroke ever can — is consistently recommended across coaching sources as one of the single most valuable diagnostic tools available, precisely because many of these mistakes genuinely don't feel wrong from the inside even when they're clearly visible on video.
12. Why Small Corrections Produce Disproportionately Large Results in Breaststroke
It's worth closing on a point that helps explain why breaststroke technique work is often so rewarding relative to the effort involved: breaststroke is, by design, the slowest of the four competitive strokes, largely because both the arms and legs recover underwater rather than through the air, meaning a breaststroker's body pushes through considerably more frontal drag over the course of a stroke cycle than swimmers using any other stroke. This structural reality means that timing errors, which cost relatively little time in a stroke like freestyle, cost dramatically more in breaststroke specifically — a small sequencing mistake that might shave a tenth of a second off a freestyle length can cost several tenths in breaststroke, because it collapses the glide phase that the entire stroke's efficiency depends on.
The encouraging flip side of this same reality is that fixing even a fairly minor technical issue in breaststroke tends to produce a disproportionately large, immediately noticeable improvement in speed and efficiency — often felt within the very same session the correction is made, rather than requiring weeks of gradual adaptation. This is precisely why breaststroke rewards patient, deliberate technical work so consistently: the stroke's inherent structure means that small, targeted corrections to timing, kick width, breathing coordination, and body position translate into meaningfully faster, less exhausting swimming almost immediately, rather than requiring the kind of extended, incremental grinding that produces smaller, harder-to-notice gains in other strokes.
The Bottom Line
The common challenges covered here — mistimed pull-kick sequencing, pausing during the breath instead of the glide, chasing stroke rate at the expense of distance per stroke, an overly wide kick or pull, asymmetrical kicking, poorly timed breathing, excessive bobbing, and a rushed or mistimed underwater pullout — account for the overwhelming majority of what separates a choppy, exhausting breaststroke from a smooth, efficient one. None of them require new levels of fitness or strength to address; what they require is a genuine understanding of the sequential pull-breathe-kick-glide principle that underlies the entire stroke, a handful of targeted diagnostic and correction drills, and the patience to isolate one specific issue at a time rather than trying to fix everything simultaneously. Given how disproportionately breaststroke rewards even small technical corrections, the effort invested in getting these fundamentals right pays off faster, and more visibly, than in almost any other stroke — turning a stroke with a reputation for being frustratingly difficult into one where deliberate, patient refinement produces genuinely satisfying, immediately felt results.






Comments