Web Analytics Made Easy -
StatCounter
top of page

Common Mistakes in Freestyle and How to Correct Them

14 minutes ago
13 min read

Freestyle looks deceptively simple. Arms turn over, legs kick, head turns to breathe, repeat. But watch any lap lane at a public pool and you'll see the same handful of technical flaws showing up again and again — swimmers working hard, breathing heavily, and still moving through the water at a fraction of the speed their effort should produce. Freestyle is unusual among sports in that raw effort and speed aren't tightly linked; a swimmer with clean technique and a fraction of the exertion will consistently beat a swimmer thrashing at full intensity with poor form. The reason almost always comes down to a small set of well-documented, extremely common mistakes — and the encouraging news is that every one of them has a specific, well-tested drill designed to fix it.

This article walks through the most common freestyle errors, organised roughly from head to toe: body position and head placement, breathing mechanics, arm entry and the catch, the pull itself, body rotation, and kick technique. For each, we'll cover what the mistake looks like, why it costs you speed or energy (and sometimes injures your shoulder), and the specific drills coaches consistently recommend to correct it.


1. Lifting the Head and Looking Forward

The mistake. Perhaps the single most common flaw in recreational freestyle is looking forward — either out of habit, anxiety about not seeing where you're going, or simply never having been taught otherwise. Instead of keeping the gaze directed down and slightly forward toward the bottom of the pool, many swimmers keep their head up, chin forward, eyes scanning ahead the way they might while walking.

Why it matters. The body follows the head. When the head lifts, the hips and legs sink, because the body naturally rotates around its centre of buoyancy — lift the front, and the back end drops. This isn't a minor cosmetic issue; a swimmer with sinking hips is dragging their entire lower body through the water like an anchor, creating dramatically more resistance than a swimmer holding a flat, horizontal position. Every stroke has to fight through that self-created drag before it can generate any forward progress at all.

The fix. The correct head position keeps the gaze directed down and slightly forward, roughly at the pool bottom just ahead of the swimmer, rather than straight ahead at the far wall. A helpful mental cue many coaches use is imagining a laser pointer taped to the top of the head, aimed down toward the bottom of the pool a few metres ahead — the goal is to keep that imaginary beam pointed downward throughout the stroke, only shifting briefly to the side during the breath itself, never lifting forward.

Drills to fix it. Swimming with a snorkel removes the need to turn the head for breathing entirely, letting a swimmer focus purely on holding a consistent, correct head-down position without the disruption of a breath cycle. Kicking on the front with arms extended in streamline, focusing purely on holding the head still and looking down, also builds the habit before adding the complexity of a full stroke.


2. Poor Breathing Mechanics

The mistake. Breathing is where a lot of freestyle technique falls apart, and it shows up in a few different forms: lifting the head straight up to breathe instead of rotating to the side, holding the breath entirely for one or more strokes and then gasping, or breathing exclusively to one side every single time.

Why it matters. Lifting the head to breathe compounds the same hip-sinking problem described above, but concentrated specifically at the moment of the breath — exactly when a swimmer most needs stable body position to avoid disrupting their rhythm. Holding the breath, meanwhile, causes a swimmer to gasp for air on the next breath rather than exhaling and inhaling smoothly, which breaks stroke rhythm and often leads to swallowing water. Breathing exclusively to one side creates asymmetry in stroke technique and rotation over time, and also means a swimmer has literally no way to check their surroundings — a lane-mate, a wall, another swimmer — on their non-breathing side.

The fix. The breath should happen through a rotation of the body and head together, rolling to the side so that one eye and half the mouth clear the surface, rather than lifting the head or chin forward. Crucially, exhalation should happen continuously underwater between breaths — a swimmer should be blowing bubbles out through the nose or mouth the entire time their face is submerged, so that when they do rotate to breathe, they only need to inhale, not exhale and inhale in the brief window available.

Drills to fix it. Bilateral breathing — alternating breaths between the left and right side, commonly every third stroke — is widely recommended specifically to correct one-sided breathing habits and build symmetrical rotation on both sides of the body, even for swimmers who ultimately prefer breathing to one side in competition. Practising exhaling forcefully underwater during easy kick-only drills, well before adding the arm stroke back in, helps build the habit of continuous exhalation so it becomes automatic rather than a conscious effort mid-swim.


3. Crossing Over the Centreline on Hand Entry

The mistake. As the recovering arm swings forward and enters the water, many swimmers let the hand cross over the body's centreline, entering the water in front of the opposite shoulder rather than in line with their own shoulder on the same side.

Why it matters. A crossover entry causes the body to snake through the water rather than travelling in a straight line, since the resulting pull naturally sweeps the body slightly sideways with every stroke. This zig-zagging path is longer than a straight line by definition, meaning the swimmer is covering more actual distance than the pool length itself requires — wasted motion that directly costs speed for the same amount of effort.

The fix. Each hand should enter the water roughly in line with the shoulder on the same side — not out wide past the shoulder line, and not crossed over toward the midline of the body. Fingertips should enter first, followed by the hand and forearm, extending forward in a smooth, controlled reach rather than slapping down flat onto the surface.

Drills to fix it. Swimming with a swim snorkel or a light pull buoy while consciously watching hand entry position (either through peripheral vision or later reviewing video) helps build awareness of exactly where each hand is entering. Some coaches also recommend deliberately overcorrecting during drill work — entering slightly wide of the shoulder rather than narrow — to help a chronic crosser recalibrate their sense of "straight ahead," since their internal sense of centre is often already skewed toward the crossed position.


4. Dropping the Elbow During the Catch

The mistake. Once the hand enters the water and begins to press backward — the phase of the stroke known as the "catch" — many swimmers let their elbow drop below the level of their hand, effectively pulling with a straight or nearly straight arm rather than a bent one.

Why it matters. This is arguably the single most consequential technical flaw in recreational freestyle, and one that even fairly experienced swimmers frequently discover they have once their stroke is filmed and reviewed. When the elbow drops, the forearm and hand end up pushing water downward rather than backward, which does very little to propel the body forward — instead, it causes the swimmer's body to bob up and down with each stroke, wasting energy on vertical movement instead of converting it into forward speed. Research reviewing experienced competitive swimmers has specifically flagged dropped-elbow and related entry-angle issues as recurring technical problems even among athletes with over a decade of competitive experience, underlining just how persistent and easy to miss this particular flaw is. Beyond the lost propulsion, pulling with a straight arm also increases shoulder stress, since the joint works at a mechanically weaker angle than a properly bent-elbow catch — a meaningful injury risk factor for swimmers who log significant weekly distance.

The fix. The technical goal is what's often called "early vertical forearm," or EVF: as the hand enters and begins pressing down and back, the elbow should stay high while the forearm rotates to a near-vertical position, effectively turning the entire forearm and hand into one large paddle surface pushing water directly backward, rather than just the hand alone pushing water downward.

Drills to fix it. The fist drill — swimming regular freestyle strokes with the hands clenched into loose fists rather than open palms — is one of the most consistently recommended corrections for this exact problem. With the hand's surface area removed from the equation, a swimmer is forced to rely on forearm positioning to generate any propulsion at all, which builds the habit of a high-elbow, vertical-forearm catch almost automatically, since a dropped elbow with a closed fist produces almost no forward movement whatsoever — the lack of progress itself becomes the feedback. Sculling drills at the front of the stroke, moving the hands back and forth in a small figure-eight motion with elbows pitched higher than the hands, are also widely used to build a physical feel for what a proper early-vertical-forearm position should feel like before attempting to reproduce it in a full stroke.


5. Pulling in an S-Curve or Crossing Under the Body

The mistake. An older style of technique, sometimes still taught informally or picked up by imitation, has swimmers pulling their hand in a curved "S" shape underneath their body — sweeping inward toward the centreline, then outward again — rather than pulling in a straighter line directly backward.

Why it matters. While this S-curve pull was once believed to generate extra propulsion through a kind of sculling lift effect, it's now widely understood to be less efficient than a straighter pull for most swimmers, and it frequently correlates with the hand crossing under the body's midline during the pull — a related but distinct problem from crossing over on entry, happening later in the stroke cycle instead. Pulling under the body's centreline in this way reduces the amount of water being pushed directly backward and can contribute to the same snaking, inefficient path through the water that a crossover entry causes.

The fix. Rather than curving the pull into an S-shape, swimmers should aim to keep the elbow bent at roughly a right angle through the catch and pull, with fingers pointed toward the pool floor, and then pull in a comparatively straight line directly backward beneath the body, avoiding any deliberate inward sweep toward the midline.

Drills to fix it. A commonly recommended cue is having the swimmer imagine scraping their thumb along their own thigh as the hand finishes the pull near the hip — a small tactile checkpoint that helps confirm the hand travelled in a reasonably straight line back along the body's side rather than sweeping wide or curving inward beneath the belly.


6. Mistimed Stroke Coordination ("Windmilling")

The mistake. Some swimmers pull with one arm the instant the other arm begins recovering, so that both arms are essentially moving in constant opposite rotation like a windmill or fan, with no pause or overlap between strokes at all.

Why it matters. This timing issue usually goes hand in hand with poor breathing coordination, since a windmilling stroke rhythm rarely leaves a clean, unhurried window to rotate and breathe smoothly. It also tends to shorten each individual stroke's reach and power, since the arm doesn't get the chance to fully extend and set up a strong catch before the next pull begins.

The fix. A more efficient freestyle rhythm generally involves a brief moment where the extended arm holds its position out in front while the recovering arm swings through and begins to enter the water — not a full pause, but enough overlap to avoid the rushed, alternating windmill pattern.

Drills to fix it. The catch-up drill is the standard correction here: the swimmer keeps one arm extended straight out in front in a streamlined position and holds it there until the other arm completes a full stroke cycle and the two hands essentially "catch up" to meet in front, before switching. This drill can also be practised as a one-arm-only variation, swimming several lengths using only one arm while the other stays extended in streamline, which is particularly useful for building comfort breathing on a swimmer's weaker side and correcting any strength imbalance between the two arms.


7. Kicking From the Knees Instead of the Hips

The mistake. Many swimmers, especially those without formal coaching, kick primarily by bending and straightening the knee, similar to a bicycle-pedalling motion, rather than initiating the kick from the hip.

Why it matters. A knee-driven kick tends to be both less efficient and more tiring, since it relies on smaller muscle groups working harder rather than the larger hip and glute muscles doing the bulk of the work. It also frequently produces a kick with too much amplitude — the legs moving up and down excessively, or breaking the surface with a large splash — which adds drag rather than propulsion, and can cause the legs to sink if the kick isn't generating enough lift to counteract it.

The fix. An efficient freestyle kick should be thought of as originating from the hip and glutes, with the leg behaving like a whip — power initiated at the hip, travelling down through a relatively loose, slightly bent knee, finishing at a relaxed, flexible ankle with toes pointed. The kick itself should stay fairly small and compact, generally not breaking far beyond the body's own "shadow" in the water, rather than a large, exaggerated up-and-down motion.

Drills to fix it. Vertical kicking in deep water — treading water using the kick alone, with the arms held above the surface rather than assisting — is a widely recommended drill precisely because it removes any ability to cheat with the arms, forcing the hips and glutes to do the work of keeping the swimmer afloat. Being able to sustain this position for even 30 seconds with reasonable technique is often used informally as a benchmark of decent kick mechanics. Kickboard drills, focusing specifically on hip-driven movement rather than knee-bending, and drills using fins to build a stronger feel for a properly extended, whip-like kick, are also commonly used as supplementary corrections.


8. Stiff, Flexed Ankles

The mistake. Closely related to the knee-kicking problem, many recreational swimmers kick with rigid, flexed ankles — feet held at close to a right angle to the leg — rather than relaxed and pointed.

Why it matters. Stiff ankles function almost like a brake with every kick, since a flexed foot presents a flat surface that resists moving smoothly through the water rather than slicing through it, dramatically reducing the propulsive force each kick generates regardless of how much power comes from the hip.

The fix. Ankles should stay relaxed and loose throughout the kick, allowing the foot to point naturally and flex slightly with the water's resistance, rather than being deliberately held rigid.

Drills to fix it. Fin work is particularly effective here, since fins physically require a pointed-toe position to work properly and help build ankle flexibility and the correct movement pattern over repeated practice. Ankle mobility exercises done outside the pool can also help swimmers whose natural flexibility is limiting their ability to hold a relaxed, pointed position even when they understand the correct technique conceptually.


9. Losing Body Rotation

The mistake. Some swimmers keep their torso relatively flat and square to the bottom of the pool throughout the stroke, barely rotating from side to side, rather than rolling the body along its long axis with each stroke.

Why it matters. Freestyle is meant to be swum with the body rotating from hip to shoulder on each side, and losing that rotation both weakens the pull — since a flat, unrotated pull loses the additional reach and power that rotation provides — and tends to make breathing feel more forced and awkward, since a swimmer without body rotation has to rely much more heavily on neck movement alone to clear the water for a breath.

The fix. Each stroke should involve a rotation of the hips and shoulders together, rolling the body onto its side as one arm extends forward and the other finishes its pull, rather than keeping the torso flat throughout.

Drills to fix it. Side-kicking drills — kicking on one side with the bottom arm extended forward and the top arm resting along the body, head resting comfortably in the water rather than lifted — help build a feel for a properly rotated body position independent of the arm stroke, before reintroducing the full alternating stroke on top of that rotated foundation.


10. Overgliding Between Strokes

The mistake. In an attempt to feel smoother or more "efficient," some swimmers deliberately extend a long pause after each arm entry, gliding motionless for an extended moment before beginning the next catch and pull.

Why it matters. While a very brief glide can be part of good technique, an exaggerated pause allows the swimmer to decelerate noticeably between strokes, meaning each new stroke has to accelerate the body from a near-stop rather than maintaining continuous momentum — a much less energy-efficient pattern than a stroke rhythm with only a brief, natural pause.

The fix. The extended arm should transition into the catch phase promptly once the recovering arm is roughly halfway through its swing forward, rather than waiting for a long, deliberate glide to finish first.

Drills to fix it. Swimming at a slightly higher stroke rate than feels natural during drill sets, deliberately shortening the pause at full extension, helps recalibrate a swimmer's sense of timing away from the overglide habit, while still maintaining the reach and extension that makes freestyle efficient in the first place.


Putting It All Together: How to Actually Fix Multiple Mistakes at Once

It's rare for a swimmer to have only one of these issues in isolation — most recreational freestylers carry a combination of several at once, and trying to fix everything simultaneously mid-stroke is generally a recipe for frustration rather than progress. The more effective approach, consistently recommended across swim coaching resources, is to tackle one specific correction at a time: pick a single mistake, dedicate a focused block of drill work to it using the isolating drill described above, and only once that correction starts to feel more natural, layer it back into full-stroke swimming before moving on to the next issue on the list.

Filming your own stroke, even briefly with a phone in a waterproof case propped at the end of a lane, is one of the most consistently recommended tools across coaching sources for this exact reason — many of the mistakes described here are essentially invisible from the swimmer's own perspective, since they don't necessarily feel wrong internally even though they're clearly visible from an external, trained eye or a camera lens. A short ten-minute review of your own footage after a session will often reveal a specific, fixable flaw far faster than months of unguided swimming ever could. Where possible, working with a coach who can watch from the pool deck in real time and give immediate, specific feedback speeds this process up considerably further, since a coach can flag a fault the very moment it happens rather than waiting for a session-ending video review.


The Bottom Line

The mistakes covered here — lifting the head, poor breathing mechanics, crossing over on entry, dropping the elbow, an inefficient S-curve pull, mistimed windmill strokes, kicking from the knees, stiff ankles, losing body rotation, and overgliding — account for the overwhelming majority of what separates a struggling recreational freestyler from a smooth, efficient one. None of them require extraordinary athleticism to fix; they require awareness, targeted drill work, and patience, since technical habits that have often been reinforced over years of unguided swimming don't disappear after a single session. Pick one mistake, drill it specifically using the corrections above, confirm the change is sticking through video or coach feedback, and move to the next. Freestyle rewards precision far more than raw effort — and once the drag-creating habits are cleaned up one at a time, the same amount of exertion in the water tends to produce a noticeably faster, smoother, and less exhausting stroke.

Comments


bottom of page